Constructive Trust Example A parent who promises to leave certain real property to the child in exchange for care and companionship but transfers that property to another person. An ex-spouse takes funds rightfully belonging to an ex-spouse or her children and purchases real property with a new spouse.
Table of Contents
What are the elements of a constructive trust?
The elements of a constructive trust are: (1) a promise; (2) transfer of the property and reliance thereon; (3) a confidential relationship; and (4) unjust enrichment. See Bergmann v. Slater, 922 So.
What does constructive trust mean in law?
A constructive trust is not an actual trust by the traditional definition but a trust created through a court’s power, over assets they determine a party cannot equitably keep. It is a legal fiction that is used as a remedy for unjust enrichment.
How do you impose a constructive trust?
In order for a constructive trust to be imposed, the defendant must own the property. Constructive trusts are imposed by a court in order to avoid unjust enrichment of the person who is holding the property on behalf of another person.
What is constructive trust in family law?
A constructive trust is an equitable remedy (based on fairness) in which the court “constructs a trust” in favour of the non-owner spouse.
How do you prove a common intention constructive trust?
- there must have been a common intention that each joint owner would have a particular interest in the property.
- there must be evidence of express discussions giving rise to the common intention.
Are constructive trusts complicated?
A ‘constructive trust’ is a more complex area of law and happens when there is an agreement, arrangement , understanding or promise between the two parties.
Does a constructive trust need to be in writing?
Although the requirement may differ depending on whether it is created inter vivos or via a will, the fact still remains that generally speaking, the terms of the trust must be evidenced in writing.
What are the duties of a constructive trustee?
The term ‘constructive trust’ is used in various senses when identifying a remedy provided by a court of equity. The trust institution usually involves both the holding of property by the trustee and a personal liability to account in a suit for breach of trust for the discharge of the trustee’s duties.
What is the effect of a constructive trust?
⇒ Constructive trusts will give rise to equitable interests: The beneficiary will have an interest in the trust property. Gains and losses become the property of the beneficiary. Priority over general creditors of the constructive trustee.
What will give rise to a constructive trust?
Where two parties make a will in pursuance to such an agreement, a constructive trust may arise, if one party breaches the agreement by revoking his will. The personal representative and alternative beneficiaries hold subject to a constructive trust is imposed for the benefit of the original beneficiaries.
What kinds of contributions will trigger a constructive trust?
Constructive Trust – relates to the consequence of the conduct of the party towards the property such as contributing towards mortgage repayments after purchase and renovation works that add value to the property.
Is constructive trust equitable?
In family law, a constructive trust is an equitable remedy that gives a person an interest in a spouse’s property when the person has contributed to the purchase, maintenance or improvement of the property, and it would be unconscionable for the spouse to retain the sole benefit of the joint endeavour.
What is the difference between an equitable lien and a constructive trust?
An equitable lien is a claim on property by someone other than the owner when an unpaid debt is owed. A constructive trust is a transfer of property to someone other than the owner, when the owner wrongfully acquired the property.
Is constructive trust personal remedy?
The right to a constructive trust is generally an alternative remedy. The aggrieved party can choose between a trust and other relief at law, such as recovery of money wrongfully taken, but cannot obtain both types of relief.
What is unjust enrichment in divorce?
Since common-law partners usually don’t get a share of each other’s property, you have to prove why you should be given a share. A claim based on unjust enrichment means that it would be unfair to allow your partner to leave the relationship without sharing their property.
What is unjust enrichment constructive trust?
Resulting Constructive Trust Unjust Enrichment lawyers deal with cases where someone put up money or effort with an expectation they would receive value in return.
What does implied resulting or constructive trust mean?
Resulting or presumed trust- the matter is dealt with legally, taking into account all of the evidence. In a resulting trust one person confers title to property on another but refrains beneficial ownership of it. Constructive Trust, created for the purpose of being fair to each party.
What are the two major fundamental requirements in order to prove acquisition under a constructive trust?
This requires two matters to be demonstrated: (a) that there was a common intention that both should have a beneficial interest; (b) that the claimant has acted to his or her detriment on the basis of that common intention.
How do you prove common intentions?
To prove the charge of common intention, the prosecution has to establish by evidence, whether direct or circumstantial, that there was plan or meeting of minds of all the accused persons to commit the offence for which they are charged with the aid of Section 34, be its pre-arranged or on the spur of the moment; but …
What is the difference between a resulting trust and constructive trust?
A resulting trust differs from a constructive trust in that it gives effect to the presumed intention of the parties, rather than their express intentions.
What is a half secret trust?
A half secret trust is where the Will creates a trust, but it does not reveal any of the details, for example, who the beneficiaries are. Usually, the Will would leave the gift to a trustee to hold on trust “for purposes already communicated to them”.
How do you prove beneficial interest in a property?
The most common way to create a beneficial interest is through an express trust. This is where the legal owner signs a trust deed or written agreement declaring that the legal owner holds the property ‘on trust’ for someone else, the beneficial owner.
Are constructive trusts remedial?
A remedial constructive trust only arises when an applicant claims compensation which fails to fall neatly into any of the accepted categories of trust or other remedy.
How does a constructive trust prevent a fiduciary from profiting?
The constructive trust (a proprietary claim) possesses superior disgorgement properties relative to an account of profits (a personal claim). The recognition of a constructive trust of fiduciary gain therefore reduces the expected benefit of and incentive for fiduciary disloyalty.